[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: Weintraub's MacARTHUR'S WAR



Thanks for the post - an interesting take on the American Caesar.
 
When I was with the Students Army (aka - "partisans") in North Korea, MacArthur was a hero and a god to me. Among other things, his 'Home by TG', 'Home by Xmas' had meant a great deal for me, because it meant home-coming for me, too.
 
In 1945, my family, a landlord in Kapsan, was mobbed by a gang of peasants (formerly our tenant farmers) and we barely escaped with our lives. Since then, I dreamed everyday of going back to Kapsan and reclaiming my lost properties (my father gave me a mountain), and in 1950, Gen. MacArthur made me believe that my dream would come true.  I believed he knew what he was doing and his words were the Bible for me.  
 
By the end of 1951, however, I had come to the conclusion that I would not be climbing my mountain any time soon.  By this time, my faith in the "Great General" turned into personal hatred and contempt, perhaps as intense as that of those American GIs abandoned by the general in the Philippines once and then, more seriously, again, at Mukden, when the general embraced Gen. Ishi who used the captured GIs for BW experimentation. 
 
I am sure the good general meant well, but a man in his position should have been more careful with his promises.  He should not have promised things he could not deliver.
 
 
 
ysk
----- Original Message -----
Sent: Monday, February 18, 2002 6:36 AM
Subject: Re: Weintraub's MacARTHUR'S WAR

You all,

The review of Weintraub's work pasted to this was written early last year.  My belief that the book itself is well worth reading is still in place.  It does not hurt to recall the comment on MacArthur that I learned as a boy in the 7th Marines: "With the help of GOD--and a few Marines--MacArthur got back to the Phillipines."

Our "success" in Afghanistan has not made me revise my positive reaction to what Weintraub said.

Best regards,

Carl Bernard


MACARTHUR'S WAR, Korea and the Undoing of an American Hero
by Stanley Weintraub