The early Brewster could dogfight the Zero. As both did not use self sealing tanks or armor. They had about the same weight and power. However the Zero did have 2-20mm cannon. So Advantage Zero.
DF
SDonell73@aol.com wrote:
In a message dated 8/12/02 7:00:19 AM Pacific Daylight Time, Home@DanSources.com writes:
One of the reasons the Brewster and Wildcat did well was because they had combat range and enough gas to engage in combat and make it home. The Brewster had large gas tanks and amazing range. The Wildcat had a two stage supercharger that did well up to 20k.I read somewhere that Boyington thought the original Brewsters were as good as any fighters, but when they upgraded it to have standard fuel tanks, armor plating and electronics gear necessary for a combat environment, it wasn't worth a damn.
Apparently the Finns sure liked them when fighting the Russians.
Sandy