[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: Chosin Few



>I say this because it is important to teach Americans the
>true Korean name for "Chosin Reservoir." If you talk to
>Koreans that you fought at Chosin Reservoir, no one will understand it.
 
This is not true.  There are Koreans in the organisation who understand it.
Also - wouldn't those Koreans be the translators?  Why is it important for
Korean Nationals to understand an American English Term? 
 
 
>Likewise, by teaching Americans the wrong name, you also perpetuate the
>mistake.
 
From the perspective of someone who is not an ethnic Korean there's no
big deal concerning this.  What dangers does this mistake provide?
 
Even as recently as 8/29, in calling for a pre-emptive
>military attack on Iraq in his speech before Korean War veterans,
>even Dick Cheney repeated the mistaken name: "...the successful fighting
>withdrawal from the death trap of the Chosin Reservoir"
>That was the worst history lesson on K.W. I ever heard.
 
Really?  Don't you read North Korean versions of the war?
IS the mistaken name as bad as the grossly exagerrated casualties inflicted upon
the American forces by the DPRK or the grossly exagerrated attrocities commited by
American forces according to the DPRK? 

 
----- Original Message -----
Sent: Tuesday, September 03, 2002 11:40 PM
Subject: Re: Chosin Few

Isn't this the same thing as the Sons of Confederate Veterans in the Southern United States arguing that
Bullrun 1 and 2 should be knows as First and Second Manassas (which the South won twice). 
 
Err... except in this case there are South Koreans in the Chosin Few who apparently agree with the name.
Korean website explaining everything that's been said so far in English.
No one seems offended.
 
Here is an article in which the Korean times has a non-Korean writer who uses both.
 
 
 
The Korean Embassy doesn't edit Chosin for Changjin...
umm...
 
 
JHK - what are all your reasons why it needs to be changed to Changjin - and are you trying to convince us
or just get our reactions?   I just don't understand why you are trying to change peoples' minds on this issue.
 
----- Original Message -----
Sent: Tuesday, September 03, 2002 10:53 PM
Subject: Re: Chosin Few

Why would we even consider changing it? I think the suggestion was because it might offend some people, My answer to that is simply, if they get offended TOUGH S--T! That's the name we chose, that's the name we want. That's the name it will remain-live with it! Lee