[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: Korean War & Vietnam War



S Rhee knowing this wanted to extend the war after the signing the Cease Fire agreement.
BTW... what was the main hang up(s) getting everyone to sign.
 
D
 
 
----- Original Message -----
Sent: Saturday, December 28, 2002 3:19 PM
Subject: Re: Korean War & Vietnam War

I
wanaki@infi.net writes:

The 1950-1953 war in Korea was not a Civil War, regardless of what you may have read. It was a war of un-mitigated aggression, provoked by Stalin in an effort to bring the entire peninsula into the Communist sphere


Most of the Soviet archives and revelations from the Russians would indicate this is not the case. Stalin did NOT want to get sucked into playing mind games with Mao but Kim Il Sung played the two of them against each other. He only reluctantly gave weapons to Kim (but not of the caliber or number he provided to Mao) and was hoping that he would not provoke the US into a measurable response.

When Kim kicked off the war Stalin was not a happy camper, but restricted Soviet involvement to as little as possible until after Inchon. When it appeared that MacArthur was going to roar up the peninsula and was rumbling about going into Manchuria, both he and Mao reacted.

The air war illustrates Stalin's lack of enthusiam and fear of provoking a general US response in that he only permitted the use of defensive weapons (e.g. fighters) and limited where they could go to avoid a "smoking gun" which the US could use as a reason to trigger a wider theater war. Likewise, once Stalin died and internal Kremlin politics for succession took over, the Soviet support for the war vanished and the DPRK had to essentially agree to terms of a ceasefire.

Even if the Chinese had another million troops ready to go, it appears Mao did not want to waste them here either.

The lack of support by the two biggest "bullies" on the block really cut the legs out from under Kim, and was the reason that the ceasefire came into being.

Cookie Sewell
AMPS