[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

[KOREAN-WAR-L:11357] Re: MASH ethics



Taking a hill just to prove we could is just "an investment in management ego" and is, in my mind, criminal.
 
Have at it with your funny story about MASH, John. I need a laugh right now.
J. Charles Cheek (another John)
 
On Thu, 12 Feb 2004 13:58:39 EST <Jwscpd8@aol.com> writes:
In a message dated 2/11/2004 8:50:35 PM US Mountain Standard Time, kane_ca@yahoo.com writes:
could a soldier complain to a NCO about
a tactic? Or to a higher-up? 
Complaining to anyone higher than an NCO was out of order, except if you were on very good terms with your Ptln leader, the Lieut.  Complaining was an outlet for your frustrations as the lower ranks had to obey orders without question.
 
If you remember the movie called Pork Chop Hill, that hill was taken just before the truce talks really started up and was only taken to prove to the Chinese, that we, the American Army could take what we wanted and when we wanted.  After all the men we lost, the hill was abandoned to the Chinese as not being valueable.  I was not there for that attack, as I had gone home in Oct. of 1951, but I had talked to men (kids really) who were there.
 
 
I have a true funny story about a MASH unit if you want it.  Let me know.
 
   John Sonley Korea 1951
 
 
 

        Stay safe, buddy.
        J. Charles Cheek   (John)
        Author of "Stay Safe, Buddy" (ISBN 159286631X)
        A Novel about Humor & Horror during the Korean War
        www.authorsden.com/jcharlescheek